Side-by-Side Comparison
Compare Divorce Lawyers
Pick any two Pinellas County divorce attorneys and see their track records side by side — objective counts from public court records, 2020–2026. No reviews, no star ratings, no scores.
Track Records Compared
Objective counts from Pinellas County dissolution-of-marriage court records, 2020–2026. Em dashes mean the value is not available in public records. Neither column is “better” — these are facts, not scores.
| Metric | Charles D. ScottThe Law Offices of Charles D. Scott, PLLC | Kathryn CollierPinellas Family Lawyer PLLC |
|---|---|---|
| Years licensedFlorida Bar | 33 | 9 |
| Pinellas dissolutions of recordAll-years dissolution-of-marriage cases | 218 | 178 |
| Active last 12 monthsCases filed in the last year | 6 | 35 |
| Final judgmentsCases ending with a signed final judgment | 12 | 99 |
| DismissedCases closed without a final judgment | 0 | 10 |
| Settlement rate *See caveat below — not a win rate | 41.7% | 42.4% |
| Cases with childrenCustody and timesharing involved | 7 | 58 |
| Expert-witness casesCases with experts in the docket | 7 | 52 |
| Motions per caseAverage filings per case | 5.3 | 2.6 |
| HearingsDocketed hearings across cases | — | — |
| BadgesDeterministic, threshold-based — hover for criteria | Veteran | Very activeHandles complex |
* Settlement rate: Share of final judgments with a settlement agreement in the docket. Dismissals are not counted as settlements, and most private settlements never appear in dockets.
How They Match Up
Every sentence below is generated from the same fixed count templates for every pair of attorneys — filled in from public court records, with the data source and time window labeled on each block. Higher counts are facts of record, not recommendations, and nothing here measures skill or predicts outcomes.
Experience
Pinellas: Clerk portal-verified dissolutions of record (all years) · Hillsborough: derived from 13th Circuit clerk case records (not portal-verified) · Florida Bar years licensed · filings in the last 12 months
- Charles D. Scott has 218 Pinellas dissolution cases of record vs Kathryn Collier's 178 — 40 more cases of record for Charles D. Scott. A larger count means more documented Pinellas dissolutions, nothing more.
- Charles D. Scott has been licensed 33 years vs Kathryn Collier's 9 — a 24-year difference in time licensed, not a measure of ability.
- In the last 12 months, Charles D. Scott appeared in 6 newly filed cases vs Kathryn Collier's 35 — 29 more recent filings for Kathryn Collier.
Filing Style
Analyzed 2020–2026 Pinellas docket sample
- Charles D. Scott files an average of 5.3 motions per case vs Kathryn Collier's 2.6 — a higher-motion litigation pattern for Charles D. Scott (2.7 more motions per case on average). Motion volume is a docket count, not a quality measure.
Documented Tendencies
Analyzed 2020–2026 Pinellas docket sample
- 5 of Charles D. Scott's 12 sampled final judgments had a settlement agreement visible in the docket (41.7%).
- 42 of Kathryn Collier's 99 sampled final judgments had a settlement agreement visible in the docket (42.4%).
- Charles D. Scott's sampled cases: 12 ended in final judgments, 0 closed without one (dismissed).
- Kathryn Collier's sampled cases: 99 ended in final judgments, 10 closed without one (dismissed).
Settlement figures count only settlement agreements visible in the docket — dismissals are not counted as settlements, and most private settlements never appear in dockets. This is a docket-visibility measure, not a win rate.
Judge Overlap
Case assignments in the analyzed 2020–2026 Pinellas docket sample — appearance counts, not outcomes
Both attorneys have appeared before 8 of the same judges in the analyzed sample. Appearance counts say how often each attorney has worked in that courtroom — nothing about results there.
| Judge | Charles D. Scott | Kathryn Collier |
|---|---|---|
| Evan Frayman | 1 case | 13 cases |
| Julie L. Sercus | 1 case | 9 cases |
| Elizabeth Jack | 2 cases | 7 cases |
| Steve D. Berlin | 3 cases | 5 cases |
| Benjamin Thomas | 1 case | 5 cases |
| Jack Helinger | 1 case | 5 cases |
| Brian Gnage | 2 cases | 2 cases |
| Rebecca Hamilton | 1 case | 1 case |
Head-to-Head
These attorneys have faced each other in 2 cases.
1 final judgment · 1 dismissed
In those shared cases, Charles D. Scott was on the petitioner side 1 time and the respondent side 1 time — Kathryn Collier the reverse.
50% FJ, 50% dismissed across 2 cases. No dominant pattern.
Most recent shared case filed 2024-07-12
Most Experience Against
Attorneys with the most documented cases opposite each of these two — useful if you are interviewing counsel and the other side has already retained one of them. Appearance counts are from public court records.
Opposite Charles D. Scott
Deduped head-to-head case counts, 2020–2026 docket sample
- Sean A. Costis2 final judgments · 0 dismissed2 cases
- Kevin Fantauzzo1 final judgment · 1 dismissed2 cases
Opposite Kathryn Collier
Deduped head-to-head case counts, 2020–2026 docket sample
- Kim Kaszuba1 final judgment · 2 dismissed3 cases
- Patrick F. Gaffney1 final judgment · 1 dismissed2 cases
- Laurie Sweet1 final judgment · 1 dismissed2 cases
- Shelly Beach0 final judgments · 2 dismissed2 cases
- K. Dean Kantaras1 final judgment · 1 dismissed2 cases
Based on public court records covering 143 Pinellas County divorce attorneys, 2020–2026 · Data updated May 8, 2026 · How these rankings work